Review: Antara Duo at Christ Church, Skipton

Skipton Music continued its current season with a concert by the Antara Duo of Thomas Hancox (flute) and Rachel Wick (harp) – an unusual combination nowadays if more familiar in times past.

There were many delightful moments to savour in this concert by these two highly talented and persuasive musicians.

In the first half we heard two contrasting pieces from the “belle époque” of this combination, the “Valse Mélancolique” of the rarely-heard composer Clémence de Grandval and the “Morceau de Concours” by the much better known Gabriel Fauré.

Later in the concert Rachel gave a spell-binding account of the last movement of Benjamin Britten’s “Suite for harp”, making one wish she had played the earlier movements as well!

In between came “King Herla” composed for the duo by the British composer Robert Saxton and telling the sad story of the mythical king who falls prey to the elves; the haunting ending, with the plaintive sound of alto flute, was particularly effective.

Your reviewer did not however find the concert as a whole entirely satisfying.

The duo sought to create a varied and adventurous programme, but many of the pieces seemed to revert to a similar pattern, with an elaborate but somehow soulless flute part floating high above a subordinate harp accompaniment.

The concluding suite from George Bizet’s “Carmen”, arranged by the flute maker François Borne to show off the capabilities of the instrument, was a case in point – the famous tunes were all there, but the spirit of this most sensuous of operas was somehow “lost in transcription”.

The duo’s encore was a refreshing contrast – a simple yet exquisite arrangement of “Down by the Sally gardens” with the two instruments in real partnership with one another. A lovely way to end a fascinating evening.

Skipton Music’s next concert is on Tuesday, February 18 in Christ Church, Skipton, with a varied programme given by the A4 Brass Quartet.

Charles Dobson